The Inn at Cooperstown, a Select Registry Property

$10 for non-guests to charge for any length of time. Easy walk to anywhere in downtown Cooperstown, which actually made it more convenient than the public parking lots. (Public parking downtown is metered and has a 2-hour limit. The all-day lots are further away and require a long walk or trolley ride.) Plenty of food options and tons of baseball-themed shopping nearby, along with the Baseball Hall of Fame itself. We spent much of the day at the museum, ate lunch at Doubleday Cafe, and ate dinner at Nicoletta's. Overall we enjoyed all of it. The inn itself looks quite nice, and we'd certainly consider staying there in the future if our plans allow for it.